One outcome of the Blending Initiative was the inception of the Clinical Trials Network (CTN), a 17 site regional research and training center which collaborates with many community treatment programs to study the effectiveness of specific interventions in diverse community settings and patient populations. Other efforts to increase access to CBT and other evidence-based treatments for SUDs are also underway.75-77 Future research focusing on methods to bridge the gap between theory and practice in a way that supports community clinicians so that systemic change can truly be effective is of particular importance. As this paper has reviewed, many effective behavioral techniques for the treatment of substance use have been identified; however, use of such techniques is often scarce or non-existent in service provision settings. The literature provides a somewhat complex narrative on the efficacy of combined CBT and pharmacotherapy. In the largest trial to date, the added benefit of the combination was not observed, but review data suggest some benefit, and particularly for adding pharmacotherapy to CBT for alcohol use disorder.
The Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in Treating Addiction
- From a public health perspective, these programs can broaden access to an evidence-based treatment for the population of individuals with substance-use problems who do not receive care due to limited availability, costs, stigma, concerns about confidentiality, or other reasons (Carroll & Kiluk, 2017).
- Although CBT for substance abuse is characterized by heterogeneous treatment elements such as operant learning strategies, cognitive and motivational elements, and skills-building interventions, across protocols several core elements emerge that focus on overcoming the powerfully reinforcing effects of psychoactive substances.
- Our comprehensive inpatient residential treatment and outpatient services for addiction and mental illness provide the support and guidance needed to achieve lasting recovery.
- Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT), and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) are all commonly used for mental health and addiction treatment.
- In conclusion, this meta-analysis shows CBT efficacy, in contrast to no or minimal treatment, was moderate and durable over follow-up.
Some key questions include what type of therapy they specialize in, how long they’ve been practicing CBT to treat alcohol and drug abuse, experience treating what is alcoholism underlying mental health issues such as anxiety disorders, and whether or not they offer group sessions as well as individual ones. Finding qualified cognitive behavioral therapists for addiction treatment can be an intimidating process. It is important to take the time to research potential therapists thoroughly and ask questions during your consultation in order to ensure that you feel comfortable with the therapist you choose and that they have experience treating substance abuse issues specifically. Despite these limitations, our rigorous evaluation of meta-analyses examining CBT for SUD suggests this intervention has strong research support. This recommendation provides further support for the widespread dissemination of and training in CBT for SUD, in addition to underscoring the necessity of additional evaluation of the cost-effectiveness of CBT and advocacy around addiction treatment policy and funding. However, future research is needed to identify patient characteristics that might moderate response to CBT for SUD, such as primary SUD type, and under which circumstances CBT should be used as a standalone versus an adjunct intervention.
Primary Study Characteristic Variables
A particular barrier to effective dissemination of CBT is the lack of a system for training, supervision, and feedback to clinicians. The lack of supervision and monitoring of clinician implementation of evidence-based treatments in clinical practice suggests that CBT and other EBPs, in practice, may bear little resemblance to the more closely monitored versions of those treatments as implemented in randomized clinical trials demonstrating their efficacy (Martino et al., 2016). Robust evidence suggests the efficacy of classical/traditional CBT compared to minimal and usual care control conditions. CBT combined with another evidence-based treatment such as Motivational Interviewing, Contingency Management, or pharmacotherapy is also efficacious compared to minimal and usual care control conditions, but no form of CBT consistently demonstrates efficacy compared to other empirically-supported modalities. CBT and integrative forms of CBT have potential for flexible application such as use in a digital format. Data on mechanisms of action, however, are quite limited and this is despite preliminary evidence that shows that CBT effect sizes on mechanistic outcomes (ie, secondary measures of psychosocial adjustment) are moderate and typically larger than those for AOD use.
Identifying Thoughts and Behaviors
To provide accurate empathy to patients, and to ascertain the optimal combination of validation for the status quo versus action toward change, it is important for therapists to assess the patient’s “stage of change.” Some patients are quite committed to giving up their addictive behaviors, and thus are at a high level of readiness for change. Similarly, patients who are uncertain cbt for substance use disorders about giving up drinking and drugging may present for treatment with the goal of “cutting back” on alcohol and other drugs. Such patients may disagree that they will need to eliminate their use of psychoactive chemicals, and may decide to leave therapy if the therapist insists that the goal must be abstinence.
Sensitivity Analyses
By improving communication and resolving conflicts, patients can develop healthier connections and support systems that reduce their risk of relapse. Regular engagement in IPT not only fosters self-awareness and coping skills but also mitigates feelings of loneliness and depression often linked to substance use. In conclusion, this meta-analysis shows CBT efficacy, in contrast to no or minimal treatment, was moderate and durable over follow-up. Consistent with a number of evidence-based addictions therapies, CBT effect sizes were small to non-significant in contrast to non-specific and specific therapies, respectively. The majority of derived effects were homogeneous, suggesting that the selected subgroup variables (i.e., contrast type, outcome type, and follow-up time point) were informative modifiers of CBT effects5. In this approach, there is an assumed distribution for the population effect size with both systematic and random sources of variability (Hedges & Vevea, 1998).
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) mandates that insurance providers must cover treatment for mental health and substance use treatment.10 This means that your insurance plan is required to cover at least a portion of your care. The ACA applies to all insurance companies, including employer-sponsored coverage, Medicaid and Medicare, and marketplace insurance. To clarify key terms used in this manuscript, the term substance use is defined as taking any illicit psychoactive substance or improper use Pof any prescribed or over the counter medication. Symptoms of substance abuse reflect the external consequences of problematic use such as failure to fulfill role obligations, legal problems, physically hazardous use, and interpersonal difficulty resulting from use. Symptoms of substance dependence reflect more internal consequences of use such as physical withdrawal upon discontinuation of a substance and difficulty with cutting down or controlling use of a substance.
CBT Effect by Contrast Type, Outcome Type, and Follow-up Time Point
If you or someone you know is struggling with substance abuse, consider seeking out qualified professionals who specialize in Cognitive behavioral therapy for addiction treatment. In the first session with cognitive behavioral therapists, individuals will undergo an initial assessment process in order to create an individualized treatment plan tailored to their needs. This may include discussing past experiences with substance use or mental health issues (depression, anxiety disorders, bipolar disorder…) as well as any other factors that may be contributing to substance use disorders.
- Cognitive behavioral therapy teaches those recovering from addiction and mental illness to find connections between their thoughts, feelings, and actions and increase awareness of how these things impact recovery.
- The evaluation of CBT for SUDs in special populations such as those diagnosed with other Axis I disorders (i.e., dual diagnosis), pregnant women, and incarcerated individuals is beyond the scope of the current review, and thus the descriptions provided below focus on SUD treatment specifically.
- From a scientific perspective, these interventions offer the opportunity to better identify and isolate the essential treatment components that contribute to behavior change, thereby advancing the development of highly concentrated interventions that might one day be tailored according to patient profiles.
- Based on your responses, you may want to speak with a health care provider to ask about your symptoms and treatment options.Schedule a free consultation to speak to one of our admissions coordinators and see if IOP treatment is right for you.
- In addition, the patient could evaluate evidence from past holidays to compare the consequences and benefits of alcohol use in these settings.
A relative limitation of CM is the availability of funds for providing the reinforcers in clinical settings. The establishment of job-based reinforcements have been introduced as alternatives to aid the clinical adoption of these methods.21, 22Also, contingency management strategies have also been incorporated into couple’s interactions (utilizing the reinforcers available to the couple) to aid the reduction of drug use (see below). Sustainable recovery is possible and the best version of youself awaits at our Atlanta and Savannah, Georgia addiction recovery center. We’ll give you skills to discover your self-worth and show you the tools for a life of hope and promise. The inverse-variance weighted effect size was calculated for each study and pooled under random effects assumptions.
Leave a Reply